Playing for the Kid and Mommy Teams

I find myself in an interesting place. I’m a grown-up, but barely so. I have friends that are over 30 and under 10. I can go to the ATLOS playgroup and discuss discipline issues with the mommies, then play on the slides with the kids. I play for both teams.

I’ve always kind of felt in between. It’s fun: the kids don’t think I’m boring and the adults don’t think I’m incapable, but it is awfully strange sometimes. But certain events these past few days have hammered home that I really do teeter the line between adult and kid.

Ways in Which I Play for the Mommy Team:

  • I babysit Jenn’s kids and for the first time ever, Ryan got into a lengthy negotiation with me. He showed big emotions and took every chance to nitpick my babysitting and bemoan how unfair I was. Then, a few weeks later, he had a play push fight with me then snuggled up to me and sat on my lap. I was shocked (since Ryan NEVER wants physical contact) and starting waving my hands at Jenn and Kelly while silently mouthing, “Holy crap look!” I’ve been assured that both gestures are a sign he’s comfortable with me.
  • I practice Positive Discipline with the kids (or try my best to) while teaching and babysitting and am not afraid to let them know when their behavior is unacceptable.
  • I was an active and willing participant in a mommy discussion about poop at the ATLOS Christmas party.
  • Kids in my sign language class a) asked me if I was married and b) said I was old.

Ways in Which I Play for the Kid Team:

  • I will sometimes act less than adult in public places by making faces or noises with the kids. Then they get scolded for bad behavior that I aided and abetted. Oops.
  • When I’m not 100% in the adult conversation going on, I’ll wander off and play with the kids.
  • I frequently get dirty stares from my friends when they make 80s pop culture references that I’ve never heard of.
  • Sometimes I accidentally cuss with my teenage students. And I feel silly teaching kids only a few years younger than me.
  • I want to go to the Messy Party and get messy.
  • I’m just as into Avatar: The Last Airbender and silly YouTube videos as the kids are.

I suppose one day I’ll grow all the way up and might even have kids of my own, officially cementing my placement on the Mommy Team. But for now I’m enjoying being a double agent.

Atlanta Objectivist Society Fall Picnic Photos

The picnic was a blast. I had so much fun shooting portraits of my friends and their families. I haven’t shot anything in a while, so it was great to get back to the camera. After the portraits we hung out and chatted while the kids played. I only wish I could have played a bit as well on that sweet playground. :)

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Child Beauty Pageants: Right or Wrong?

Child beauty pageants have been on my mind lately. I know some people that enroll their children in pageants, but I’ve never been to one myself.  The most experience I have is some clips from pageant shows like Toddlers & Tiaras on TLC. Given that, I’m talking purely about my thoughts on pageants without any real first-hand experience. (Though I’d like to go to one just once to see what it’s all about.)

So what happens at a beauty pageant? What is it? Essentially a beauty pageant is a contest over physical attractiveness. Some contests have portions of that focus on talent and interview, but a majority of the points come from the beauty and grace of the contestants as well as their outfits. Contestants try to sway the judges by having the brightest smile, cutest clothes, and prettiest hair. Some pageants allow makeup, others don’t. Some contests are small, usually held at local community centers and fairs. Others a larger and part of a national circuit. Some are judged by a panel, others are open to public votes. Procedures differ from pageant to pageant, but essentially the point is to try to convince somebody else that your child is the prettiest.

Given that, I ask, why would somebody enter their child in a pageant? If a parent walked in on a group of kids fighting over who had the best dress or the prettiest face, most people would suggest that all the girls are pretty, or that everyone is different and the shouldn’t compare themselves to each other. So why does the involvement of a stage and judges make such a contest okay?

I can understand why parents enter their children in pageants. There’s a ton of reasons, both good and bad:

  • Build confidence and self-esteem
  • Learn social skills, poise, and public speaking
  • Push children to be the best
  • Win cash prizes and scholarships
  • Have fun dressing up children in fantastic frocks, makeup, and hairdos
  • Live through children to achieve goals not earned in life
  • Encourage a talent
  • Bragging rights among other parents
  • Children enjoy performing
  • Exposure for bigger gigs like modeling or acting
  • Engage in competition
  • Promote good behavior (winners can lose their crowns if found acting inappropriately, but that’s mostly older contestants)

Bad reasons aside, I don’t think it’s wrong to want many of the things listed above. But I don’t think one needs to enter a pageant to do so. Kids can learn healthy competition, explore talents, win scholarships, build social skills, perform, and gain confidence in numerous ways through physical, social, and academic activities. Even the fun of crazy outfits and hair can be met in a game of dress up. Children can do all of these things without being subjected to the scrutiny and value judgement given by a panel or audience.

I can imagine by this point that some would call a pageant healthy competition. There are winners and losers in sports and kids can handle that. What’s the difference with a pageant? Well, I think the major difference is that in sports or academic style competitions, children are judged on their talents and skills. If a child doesn’t win, they can refine their skills, work harder, and sometimes must accept that some are more talented. But what do you tell a child that doesn’t place at a pageant? She isn’t pretty enough? She should build her hair higher and her makeup thicker? Or she should accept that some girls are just prettier? I think in a beauty contest there isn’t room for action. Sure, you can always buy more clothes and work on a child’s talent, but it still boils down to who is the prettiest in the eyes of the judges. And I think that’s an unfair and pointless contest. At least in other competitions children are encouraged to improve athletic or academic skills when they fail. But pageants just promote more obsession over looks and how others perceive them. I think it cripples children into constantly working for the opinions of others, rather than themselves.

And I think that’s the heart of the evil of it. The whole aim of the pageant, from buying clothes to practicing smiles to putting on makeup for the event, is to persuade the judge to think that your child is the most beautiful. It’s all about the subjective opinion of somebody else. It sends the message that your child’s value rests not in herself, but in the hands of other people.

And while the placement in a pageant may not matter to most kids and may not have long standing effects, why would you put your child in that situation in the first place? I don’t think the arguments for child pageants have any legs to stand on. Whatever benefits there might be are not worth the means and can be achieved in more healthy ways.

If anyone has any further (respectful) comments, pro or con, I’d like to hear them.

My Life in Atlanta So Far, Part 1: Nannyland

Consider this my public statement about what’s been going on. Cause I’m getting tired of splainin’ it over and over.

I moved from Kentucky to Atlanta at the end of July. I started a live-in nanny job, which I found great because I didn’t have to worry about rent or food and the weekly pay was mostly fun money. The family was nice enough. Mom, dad, and two girls, ages 2 and 6. They were Catholic/Presbyterian, but they didn’t make a big deal about my atheism, and I wasn’t asked to do anything religious. It wasn’t a big deal except for a ghastly magnet on their fridge for kid’s soccer that featured a quote about only being truly Christian once we’ve died on the cross like Christ. Seriously, WTF? The rest I could ignore. I lived in the basement, next to the father’s office. I worked 40 hours a week, helped out with some community chores like dishes, and often ate dinner with the family. The kids were not hellions, but they were not easy. The two-year-old was of course, two, and in the thick of potty training. (Translation: poop. Lot of poop. And not just inside her pull ups or in the toilet. I’m talking in the tub, on the carpet, and on her clothes. And on me.) The six-year-old was polite and creative, but was very emotional and often dealt with issues by yelling and then melting. The parents were very much child centered. They rarely watched anything on tv that was not animated or geared towards school-aged kids and below. In the car it was lullabies and Strawberry Shortcake videos. The mother on a number of occasions scoffed at family movies that contained humor or references aimed at adults and parents who were “too hip” to not play nursery rhymes all the time. The kids had two playrooms with toys pouring out from every shelf. The closets were similar, packed so tight with clothes it was difficult to hang up clean clothes. And there were more packed in boxes. The parents often admitted the kids had way too many toys and outfits, yet they often got more every other week or so. They lived quite comfortably.

Before I took the job I looked specifically for nanny gigs for several reasons:

  1. I like kids. And I enjoy reading and learning about Positive Discipline.
  2. Most jobs were live-in, so I got a place to live and a job all in one. No worrying over rent or food budgeting, because that was included. And living with a family had the perks of cable, internet, and access to other services I normally could not afford.
  3. It was a quick ticket to Atlanta.

My visions of working as a nanny often starred me as the hip nanny wearing fabulous thrifted dresses, jetting about town with the kids to cool sites and teaching them all about the world. I would live comfortably and enjoy my work. I would put into practice everything I had read about PD and problem solving with kids. I would go to playdates with my mommy friends in Atlanta and it would all be just great.

If you’re seeing cracks in the plan already, you’re way ahead. See, I have a tendency to idealize things and overlook gritty details, such as poop. And tantrums. And Dora the Explorer. When looking at nanny gigs and interviewing, I didn’t take a hard look at the hours and job duties and then really think about if I wanted to do them. I was stuck in my glossy cool nanny dream. And obsessed with just being in Atlanta already. Here’s the reality: there would be no time for all these adventures because I mainly worked on weekdays after the kids came home. You can’t jet off to the zoo or art museum and still do dinner with the family, homework, and have a bath all before 8 pm. So my days were mostly spent at home. My typical day included picking the kids up from school, playtime, getting the six-year-old ready for afterschool activities, feeding, bath time, brushing teeth, reading a story, and putting the kids to bed. It was a daily routine, not the various adventures I had planned for. Already my hopes were dashed, but I could have seen it coming if I had considered the details.

Another thing I should have spotted was the consequences of living with your boss. Even though I had specific hours, it wasn’t like any other job where I clocked out and left. Even after I was done, I was still there, among job. I left the house whenever I could because I never seemed to get away from the job. I constantly felt on edge and watched whenever I was in the presence of the parents. And even when I wasn’t on duty, I still felt like I was obligated to clean or keep an eye on the kids or do something. Even my room wasn’t totally private. The dad worked from home and during the day I could hear him clacking on his keyboard, and I’m sure he could hear me too. To make phone calls I had to step outside because there wasn’t a private place in the house. Towards the end of my stint I once cut a call short because I was being eaten up by mosquitos. I was livid that I had been reduced to such measures just for a private phone call. I was constantly stressed out during my time off, to the point of tears and muscle aches, and I should have been using that time to recharge and relax.

What really put me over the edge was discipline. I thought that I would do well and I still think I did okay. I never smacked a child and walked away if I thought I was going to burst. I tried to assume positive intent and validate feelings. I let both girls tantrum and cry as much as they needed and was there to talk when they were more calm. But even then, it sucked. Big time. Every day I could expect battles. Battles over eating, leaving the house, putting on shoes, putting away toys, and getting along with siblings. The sibling battles were probably the worse. Often the six-year-old wanted to set up something elaborate and play by herself. Then clambers in the two-year-old, knocking everything over, screaming, “Share! Share!” Meltdowns ensue. At the end of my shift I had a pounding head and neck ache. It happened every day. And it wore me the hell out.

As my friend Kelly put it, I was doing all the grunt work without any of the payoff. I didn’t love the kids. They weren’t my babies. I didn’t raise them or have hopes for their futures. I wasn’t emotionally invested, therefore all the work was without meaning for me. Parenting and discipline are long term processes, and I wasn’t in it for the long term. There was no payoff for me. And so I quickly learned that I had no interest whatsoever in disciplining other people’s children. Maybe for a short amount of time as a babysitter, yes, but not as a full time figure. I learned I would much rather interact with kids on a shorter amount of time, on a more limited basis. I don’t want to a major part of their lives, that’s their parents’ job. I’d much rather be teach a kid something and relate to their interests than be their nanny. I think I’m much more suited for short time babysitting and education. I realized it was that same disinterest that made deaf camp so hard this year. I was running around telling kids no and getting them on their schedules. I did more discipline than anything, and it sucked all the fun out of it. So yippee mistakes! I learned something about myself and where I want to go in my career.

Oh yeah, how did this all end? About 3 weeks into the job I was already miserable and looking for other jobs. I’m sure the mom caught onto this. She mentioned I seemed really frustrated, might not be right for the job, and that we’d wait and see. (Of course, she never gave me any advice for handling her children, so I think it was more of an advanced warning then a genuine “we’ll wait and see”.) I wanted to wait till I had something else lined up before I left the nanny gig, but she beat me to the punch. About a month after I started the job, she sat me down and said this was my last day of work. She said she would give me time to set something up, but that I should leave sooner rather than later so as not to confuse the girls. Translation: Get out ASAP. Naturally I wasn’t going to stay in an unwelcome house. It would have been painfully awkward. So I packed up my stuff that night and left for a friend’s house. During this discussion she also suggested that I shouldn’t work with children in the future and that had she known better she could have seen from the start that I was all wrong for the job. That was tough to hear, however wrong she might be. Yes, nannying for this particular family was not right for me, but that doesn’t mean I should never work with kids in the future. It just means I couldn’t bear hers in that specific capacity. I do intend to work with kids, just never as a nanny. Like I said, I don’t want to be all up in their business. I still look forward to teaching at a local homeschool co-op in late October. So stick that in your juicebox and suck it!

Anyways, more to come about what happened next and what is going on now.

What’s Going On

Long story short: I quit my nanny job. Since then I’ve been scrambling to secure steady work for myself as well as an apartment. I’m not out of it, but I’m getting there. There are many more details, but I don’t think I can properly blog about it all till I’m past it. I’m much to tired and emotional to write about it now. But I will eventually.

Till then I’m advertising myself for babysitting and photography work. So if you’re in the Atlanta area and would like to hire me, you can send me an email at mirandabarzey@gmail.com. My various portfolios are at mirandabarzey.com and I can email you references for babysitting.

Sundays are Good

I’ve always loved Sundays. Something about them is so relaxing and carefree. Here’s some good things about my Sunday:

  • It’s my day off!
  • Sleeping in because I don’t go to church. Yay atheism!
  • Hiking up Kennesaw Mountain in the morning and getting a beautiful view of Atlanta in the distance
  • Homemade iced coffee
  • Good music
  • The older kid is watching Signing Time for the bazillionth time and getting pretty good at the signs and memorizing the songs. Oh, how I love watching kids learn ASL!
  • Post Secret
  • Lots of downtime to leisurely work through my to-do list
  • Hanging out with friends
  • New True Blood tonight

Nanny Update

It’s been a few weeks since I started my job as a live-in nanny. As with starting any job, it’s been a bit stressful. After interacting with kids only on a limited basis, suddenly I’m in charge of two little people with their own personalities, temperaments, likes and dislikes, ups and downs, etc. It’s been an emotional roller coaster for us all figuring each other out and learning to live and work together. And as a mommy friend of mine said, I also have entered right into caring for two siblings without the luxury of having one child first, learning, and then having another one. (Cause that’s how parents do it.) Instead I have had to simultaneously figure out how to care for two children at very different points in development.

But I think I’m getting there. These past few days have been much easier for both me and the kids. I’m starting to learn who they are and and what techniques work with each one individually. When there’s a conflict or a meltdown, I can now act calmer instead of injecting myself frantically without a plan. My crying tolerance has gone up ten-fold, which enables me to handle situations smoother and with more empathy. I’m also learning tools of the trade, like how to get a preeschooler to sleep and the best ways to keep the toyroom clean.

The kids are also learning about me and my style of care. After some limits testing the first week or so, they both learned that I won’t budge over bedtime or popsicles for dinner, but they do know that I offer them freedom in other areas, such as activities for the day and (healthy) choices for snacks and meals. I hope that by being consistent, they’ll come to see me as firm, but kind.

Nannying is also my first time implementing daily the Positive Discipline techniques I’ve learned for so long, but hadn’t practiced much. I’m constantly checking the few books I have and asking advice from Jenn and Kelly. (By the way, go check out their parenting podcast Cultivating the Virtues!) PD is working great for me, but it takes a LOT of repetition. During sibling conflict (which happens multiple times a day, usually over toys), I’m constantly repeating the phrases, “What’s a better way to handle this?” or “Can we work something out?” I need to work on talking about this before conflicts happen when tension is low. I’m also validating feelings a lot, especially with the more sensitive child. When crying fits happen, I try to figure out why the child is crying, then talk about their feelings. With the older child, I’m asking many questions, letting her talk and giving lots of hugs and empathy, then when she calms down, trying to problem solve a bit. With the younger child, who can’t reason as much, I ask simple yes or no questions (Are you crying because you hit your head?) and I help her name her feelings (You seem mad/angry/frustrated!), which she often repeats back to me. Because she’s less prone to hugging and physical contact (“NO!” is a common response to me touching her while mad), I help her through her emotions by taking her to her room and letting her get it all out. We yell, punch pillows, jump on the bed, cry, throw balls, whatever. I particularly like this technique because it lets off steam for both of us and we’re both laughing by the end of it.

So, with a combination of Positive Discipline and time, I’m finding myself much more at ease in my role as nanny. Work is becoming a lot more…fun! I expect as time goes on things will only get better, especially once I trick out my car with carseats and the kids and I can be more mobile. And then I can be cool like this:

I’ll update as more unfolds!